I am not sure I agree with the reviews of the review. It's going a bit overboard for starters, but then to be even harsher it's allowing people to label perfectly good reviews as useless.
I can see why this would be a catalyst to keep idiots from posting "THAT SUXd" and "yoo ARE PooP!" but I really don't appreciate the value it's losing towards valued members of Newgrounds.
I find even myself being wary of posting a review, knowing what I say isn't just "you so cool iz da man" but even while I try to give positive feedback and point out all great and bad issues, I may not have one with the flash.
I don't fully agree with the thing, but it does not mean everyone has to listen to them. It's like an extra critic for a critic. A critic criticizes a movie then a critic criticizes the critic. Are you serious? Do we need more of this? If anyone is in agreement please let me know.
I can see where it would be very befitting to have it. However, that plays a very small part in how worthy it is to have something like this.
A waste of time in my opinion. As long as "useless" doesn't cause a negative impact (score or otherwise) on a flash author or a review, or a score, I guess it doesn't matter much.
I still think it's a weak attempt at making the site too "Rated".

Just my lame little two cents.